PetSafe Stubborn Dog Stay & or PetSafe Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence? Which PetSafe Model to Buy

As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases. This means we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you if you click through and make a purchase.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.

The petsafe stubborn dog stay vs stubborn dog in ground fence comparison highlights two distinct containment strategies for persistent pets. Both systems offer waterproof receiver collars with tone and static correction modes, ensuring your dog stays safe. The main difference lies in the boundary technology. One uses a wireless transmitter for flexible placement, while the other relies on buried wire for custom-shaped zones. You need to decide which boundary method fits your yard layout and training needs.

Boundary Technology

Wireless transmitter

In-ground buried wire

Correction Modes

Tone, static

Tone, vibration, static

Stimulation Levels

5 levels

4 levels

Minimum Dog Weight

5 lb

8 lb

Included Coverage

Collar only

500 ft wire for 1/3 acre

Choose the first if

• You need a wireless system that works with any existing PetSafe wireless transmitter.
• You want to add collars to your system without installing new boundary wire.
• You have a small dog under 8 lb that needs a compatible receiver.

Choose the second if

• You prefer a custom-shaped boundary defined by buried wire.
• Your dog benefits from vibration mode for hearing-impaired training.
• You want a complete kit with 500 ft of wire for immediate installation.

Verdict

Choose the Stubborn Dog Stay & Play collar if you already have a wireless transmitter or want flexible, wire-free containment. Select the In-Ground Fence if you need a permanent, custom-shaped boundary and value the added vibration training mode for your dog.

Stubborn Dog Stay vs In-Ground Fence

boundary technology

Edge: Tie

The Stubborn Dog Stay & Play uses a wireless transmitter to create a circular containment zone around your home or yard. This model does not require burying wire. In contrast, the Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence relies on a buried wire boundary. You can shape this wire to fit irregular yards, covering up to one-third acre initially. The in-ground system allows for custom shapes, while the wireless system offers a fixed circular range. Your choice depends on whether you prefer the flexibility of custom wiring or the simplicity of a wireless signal.

correction levels

Edge: PetSafe Stubborn Dog Receiver Collar

Both collars provide adjustable static correction to suit persistent dogs. The Stubborn Dog Stay & Play collar offers five distinct levels of static correction plus a tone-only mode. This gives you more granular control over intensity. The Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence collar provides four levels of static correction. It also includes a vibration mode alongside tone, which is helpful for hearing-impaired pets. While the wireless collar has more static levels, the in-ground collar adds vibration as a unique training tool. You should select based on whether you need more intensity steps or a vibration option.

minimum weight

Edge: PetSafe Stubborn Dog Receiver Collar

You must ensure your dog meets the weight requirements for the receiver collar. The Stubborn Dog Stay & Play collar is designed for dogs weighing five pounds or more. This lower threshold allows smaller breeds to use the system. The Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence collar requires dogs to weigh at least eight pounds. This higher minimum weight excludes smaller pets from using this specific collar. If you have a dog between five and eight pounds, only the wireless collar is suitable. Always verify your pet's weight before purchasing either system to ensure comfort and safety.

collar features

Edge: PetSafe Stubborn Dog Receiver Collar

Both collars are waterproof and fit neck sizes from six to twenty-eight inches. They both require dogs to be at least six months old. The Stubborn Dog Stay & Play collar is rechargeable, charging in two to three hours with a battery life of up to three weeks. The Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence collar is also waterproof but the data does not specify its power source or battery life in the provided text. Both include short and long contact points for different coat types. The rechargeable feature of the wireless collar is a clear practical advantage for convenience.

compatibility

Edge: Tie

Compatibility determines which transmitters your collar can work with. The Stubborn Dog Stay & Play collar is compatible with all PetSafe wireless fence transmitters. It explicitly states it is not compatible with PetSafe In-Ground Fences. The Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence collar works with all PetSafe In-Ground Fence transmitters, except for the YardMax model. You cannot mix these systems. If you already own a wireless transmitter, you must buy the wireless collar. If you have an in-ground system, you must buy the in-ground collar. They are not interchangeable.

Choose the right PetSafe system

Renters wanting quick setup

Our pick: PetSafe Stubborn Dog Receiver Collar

You need a boundary that does not require digging. This wireless model creates a circular zone around your home. It uses a transmitter instead of buried wire. The collar fits dogs 5 lb and up. You can add unlimited collars to the system. This fits your rental agreement and allows easy relocation.

Owners with custom yard shapes

Our pick: PetSafe Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence 1/3 Acre

You have a yard with irregular boundaries. This in-ground system lets you bury wire to match your property lines. It includes 500 ft of wire for up to 1/3 acre. You can expand to 25 acres later. The collar fits dogs 8 lb and up. This offers precise control over your specific yard layout.

Hearing-impaired dog owners

Our pick: PetSafe Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence 1/3 Acre

Your dog may not hear the tone signal. This system includes vibration modes alongside tone and static correction. The collar adjusts to neck sizes 6-28 inches. It fits dogs 8 lb and older. The vibration feature helps your pet learn the boundary effectively. This ensures safe containment regardless of hearing ability.

Specifications side by side

Spec	PetSafe Stubborn Dog Receiver Collar	PetSafe Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence 1/3 Acre
Boundary Range	–	1/3 acre
Boundary Shape	–	Custom-shaped
Containment Technology	Wireless transmitter	–
Correction Modes	Tone, static	Tone, vibration, static
Stimulation Levels	5 levels	4 levels
Waterproof Rating	Waterproof	Waterproof
Minimum Dog Weight	5 lb	8 lb
Target Pet	Dogs	Dogs
Features	Waterproof	–
Training Mode	Static	Static
Power Source	Rechargeable	–
Weather Protection	Weatherproof	–
Dimensions	8 × 6 × 3.75 inches	12 × 12 × 3 inches
Weight	4.8 ounces	8.48 ounces
Size	1 Count (Pack of 1)	500 ft (1/3 Acre)
Color	Red and Black	Multi-color
Model	PIF00-13672	PIG00-10777

Frequently asked questions

Does the Stubborn Dog Stay work for dogs under 8 pounds?

Yes, the Stubborn Dog Receiver Collar fits dogs starting at 5 pounds. This makes it suitable for smaller pets that might not meet the 8-pound threshold of some in-ground systems. The collar is designed to provide reliable containment without requiring in-ground wiring.

What correction modes are available on the Stubborn Dog collar?

The receiver collar offers both static correction and tone modes. You can choose the level of stimulation that works best for your dog's sensitivity. The system also includes a vibration option in the in-ground fence model, giving you multiple ways to train your pet.

Is the receiver collar waterproof for outdoor use?

Yes, the receiver collar is built to be waterproof and weatherproof. This ensures it remains functional even in rain or snow. You do not need to remove the collar when your dog plays outside, providing consistent containment regardless of the current weather conditions.

Can I add more collars to the Stubborn Dog Stay system?

Yes, the Stubborn Dog Receiver Collar is designed as a practical add-on for wireless fence systems. It allows you to expand containment for multiple dogs. You can purchase additional collars to suit more pets without needing to buy a new transmitter or boundary wire.

What is the weight of the Stubborn Dog Receiver Collar?

The receiver collar weighs 4.8 ounces. This lightweight design ensures it does not burden your dog during daily activities. The compact size fits comfortably on dogs 5 pounds and up, allowing for natural movement without causing discomfort or hindrance to your pet.

How much wire comes with the Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence?

The standard kit includes 500 feet of wire, covering approximately one-third of an acre. This length allows you to customize the boundary shape to fit your specific yard layout. You can extend the system further by purchasing additional wire splices and extensions separately.

Does the in-ground fence include vibration training modes?

Yes, the Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence system includes vibration correction modes. This feature allows you to train your dog using gentle stimuli before escalating to static correction. The combination of tone, vibration, and static modes provides a flexible training approach for stubborn dogs.

See also

• best PetSafe wireless dog fences under 300
• best PetSafe wireless dog fences for 2 Dogs
• stay cool handle vs helper handle skillet
• furbo 360 dog camera core vs 360 dog camera