PetSafe Stubborn Dog Stay & vs PetSafe Stay & Play Wireless (2026): Key Differences
Specs below are quoted from each Amazon listing. Scores are out of 10, based on listed specifications and buyer feedback. Nothing on this page was handled or measured by us.
As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases. This means we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you if you click through and make a purchase.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
When comparing the petsafe stubborn dog stay vs stay play wireless receiver collars, you are looking at two nearly identical tools for pet containment. Both offer five correction levels, waterproof designs, and rechargeable batteries that last up to three weeks. They both fit dogs weighing 5 pounds or more. The main difference lies in their target audience and physical build. One is marketed for stubborn dogs, while the other supports both dogs and cats. This guide breaks down the specific spec differences to help you choose.
Target Pet
Dogs
Dogs, Cats
Color
Red and Black
Black
Battery Indicator
Not listed
Low battery indicator
Weight
4.8 ounces
10.2 ounces
Model Number
PIF00-13672
PIF00-14288
Choose the first if
- You have a dog that requires a collar marketed for stubborn breeds.
- You prefer a lighter collar that weighs 4.8 ounces.
- You want a collar with red and black coloring.
Choose the second if
- You have a cat that needs containment in the yard.
- You want a visible low battery indicator to manage charging schedules.
- You prefer a collar that is entirely black.
Verdict
Choose the Stubborn Dog collar if you are training a dog and prefer a lighter unit. Pick the Stay & Play collar if you also have a cat or want the low battery warning. Both models provide the same core containment technology and correction levels.
Stubborn vs Stay & Play Collar Specs
Target Pet
Edge: PetSafe Stay & Play Replacement Collar
The PetSafe Stubborn Dog Receiver Collar is listed specifically for dogs. The PetSafe Stay & Play Replacement Collar data indicates it works for both dogs and cats. If you have a cat, the Stay & Play collar is the clear choice. For dog owners, both units are suitable. The Stubborn Dog model does not mention feline compatibility in its attributes. This distinction matters if you share your home with small pets. The Stay & Play collar covers a broader range of household animals based on the provided specifications. You should choose the Stay & Play collar if your cat needs containment.
Color
Edge: PetSafe Stubborn Dog Receiver Collar
The PetSafe Stubborn Dog Receiver Collar comes in a red and black color scheme. The PetSafe Stay & Play Replacement Collar is listed as black only. If you prefer a visible accent on your pet, the Stubborn Dog collar offers red accents. The Stay & Play collar is a solid black design. This difference is purely aesthetic and does not affect function. Both collars use the same black base material. You might choose the red and black option for easier visibility in tall grass. The black collar blends in more with dark fur. This is a minor preference point for most buyers.
Battery Indicator
Edge: PetSafe Stay & Play Replacement Collar
The PetSafe Stay & Play Replacement Collar includes a low battery indicator. This feature alerts you when it is time to charge the collar. The PetSafe Stubborn Dog Receiver Collar description does not mention a battery indicator. It only states the charge lasts up to three weeks. Without an indicator, you must track charging time manually for the Stubborn Dog collar. The Stay & Play collar removes the guesswork about battery status. This is a practical advantage for the Stay & Play model. You will know exactly when to recharge rather than guessing based on usage.
Weight
Edge: PetSafe Stubborn Dog Receiver Collar
The PetSafe Stubborn Dog Receiver Collar weighs 4.8 ounces. The PetSafe Stay & Play Replacement Collar weighs 10.2 ounces. The Stubborn Dog collar is significantly lighter. This makes it more comfortable for smaller dogs or pets sensitive to weight. The Stay & Play collar is more than double the weight. This difference may matter for very small animals near the 5 lb minimum. Heavier collars can be cumbersome for tiny pets. You should consider your pet's size and comfort. The lighter Stubborn Dog collar is better for smaller breeds.
Compatibility
Edge: Tie
Both collars are compatible with all PetSafe Wireless Fence transmitters. Neither works with PetSafe In-Ground Fences or Remote Trainers. This compatibility is identical for both products. You can add unlimited collars to your system with either option. The containment technology relies on a wireless transmitter for both. There is no difference in how they connect to the boundary. Both models serve the same function within the wireless ecosystem. You can mix and match collars if needed, as they share core compatibility. This aspect is a tie for both products.
Choose the right collar for your pet
Cat owner needing containment
Our pick: PetSafe Stay & Play Replacement Collar
The PetSafe Stay & Play Replacement Collar explicitly lists cats as a target pet. The Stubborn Dog model specifies dogs only. If you are containing a feline, this data-backed specification makes the Stay & Play the only viable choice. Both collars share identical wireless technology, but only one supports your cat's needs.
User wanting battery awareness
Our pick: PetSafe Stay & Play Replacement Collar
The Stay & Play collar features a low battery indicator. This spec helps you know when to charge before the collar stops working. The Stubborn Dog model lists rechargeable batteries but does not mention this specific indicator feature. If you prefer visual cues for maintenance, this specification is a practical advantage for daily use.
Dog owner prioritizing fit
Our pick: PetSafe Stubborn Dog Receiver Collar
The Stubborn Dog Receiver Collar includes short and long contact points. This spec allows you to adjust for pets with long or short hair effectively. While the Stay & Play also includes these points, the Stubborn model is marketed specifically for dogs. For a dog owner focusing on hair-specific contact adjustments, this targeted design supports your setup.
PetSafe Stubborn Dog Receiver Collar
Best for: extra collars for stubborn dogs
- Containment Technology
- Wireless transmitter
- Correction Modes
- Tone, static
- Stimulation Levels
- 5 levels
- Waterproof Rating
- Waterproof
- Minimum Dog Weight
- 5 lb
- Target Pet
- Dogs
This is a replacement receiver collar for the PetSafe Stubborn Dog Stay & Play Wireless Fence system. It features five static correction levels and a tone-only mode for training. The collar is waterproof and rechargeable, lasting up to three weeks per charge. It fits dogs weighing 5 lb or more with neck sizes between 6 and 28 inches. You can add unlimited collars to your existing wireless transmitter system.
- Five adjustable static correction levels for tailored training
- Rechargeable battery lasts up to three weeks on a single charge
- Waterproof design protects against weather and play
- Compatible with all PetSafe wireless fence transmitters
- Includes short and long contact points for different coat types
- Minimum weight requirement of 5 lb limits use for very small dogs
- Neck size range of 6 to 28 inches may not fit extremely large breeds
- Not compatible with PetSafe in-ground fences or remote trainers
- You need an extra collar for your existing wireless fence system
- Your dog weighs 5 lb or more and fits the neck size range
- You want a waterproof collar with rechargeable battery life
- You use a PetSafe in-ground fence system
- Your dog weighs less than 5 lb
- You need compatibility with remote trainers
Verdict: PetSafe Stubborn Dog Stay & Play Collar fits owners of stubborn dogs who already use the wireless fence transmitter and need a durable, waterproof replacement collar with adjustable correction levels.
PetSafe Stay & Play Replacement Collar
Best for: Wireless fence owners needing extra waterproof collars
- Containment Technology
- Wireless transmitter
- Correction Modes
- Tone, static
- Stimulation Levels
- 5 levels
- Waterproof Rating
- Waterproof
- Minimum Dog Weight
- 5 lb
- Target Pet
- Dogs, Cats
This receiver collar works with PetSafe wireless transmitters to keep pets safe. It offers five static correction levels plus a tone-only mode. The unit is waterproof and rechargeable, lasting up to three weeks per charge. It fits dogs and cats weighing 5 pounds or more with neck sizes between 6 and 28 inches. You can add unlimited collars to the system. The slim design includes short and long contact points for different coat types.
- Five levels of static correction plus tone-only mode
- Waterproof construction for outdoor use
- Rechargeable battery lasts up to 3 weeks
- Compatible with all PetSafe wireless fence transmitters
- Fits pets from 5 lb with 6-28 in necks
- Heavier at 10.2 ounces compared to lighter alternatives
- Only 5 stimulation levels available
- Requires compatible wireless transmitter, not in-ground
- You own a wireless fence system and need an extra collar
- You have pets with neck sizes between 6 and 28 inches
- You want a waterproof collar for outdoor use
- You need a collar for pets under 5 pounds
- You use an in-ground fence system
- You require remote trainer compatibility
Verdict: PetSafe Stay & Play Rechargeable Collar fits owners of wireless fence systems who need a durable, waterproof collar for pets over 5 pounds. It is a practical addition for households with multiple pets or varying coat types.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | PetSafe Stubborn Dog Receiver Collar | PetSafe Stay & Play Replacement Collar |
|---|---|---|
| Containment Technology | Wireless transmitter | Wireless transmitter |
| Correction Modes | Tone, static | Tone, static |
| Stimulation Levels | 5 levels | 5 levels |
| Waterproof Rating | Waterproof | Waterproof |
| Minimum Dog Weight | 5 lb | 5 lb |
| Target Pet | Dogs | Dogs, Cats |
| Color | Red and Black | Black |
| Features | Waterproof | Waterproof |
| Training Mode | Static | Static |
| Power Source | Rechargeable | Rechargeable |
| Weather Protection | Weatherproof | Weatherproof |
| Dimensions | 8 × 6 × 3.75 inches | 8 × 1 × 0.1 inches |
| Weight | 4.8 ounces | 10.2 ounces |
| Size | 1 Count (Pack of 1) | 1 Count (Pack of 1) |
| Model | PIF00-13672 | PIF00-14288 |
Frequently asked questions
Can the PetSafe Stay & Play collar be used on cats?
Yes. The PetSafe Stay & Play Replacement Collar explicitly lists cats as a target pet. The Stubborn Dog model specifies dogs only. If you are containing a feline, this data-backed specification makes the Stay & Play collar the suitable choice for your household needs.
What correction modes do these collars offer?
Both collars provide tone and static correction. You can adjust the intensity across five levels. This allows you to start with a gentle tone and increase to static correction if your pet ignores the warning. The training mode remains static for both units.
Are these collars waterproof for outdoor use?
Yes. Both the Stubborn Dog and Stay & Play collars are rated as waterproof and weatherproof. You can leave them on your pet during rain or play sessions without worry. This durability ensures the electronics remain safe from moisture damage in various environments.
How long does the battery last on a single charge?
The rechargeable batteries last up to three weeks on a full charge. You do not need to buy disposable batteries. Simply connect the collar to the charger when the indicator light shows low power. This reduces ongoing maintenance costs for you.
What is the weight of the receiver collars?
The Stubborn Dog collar weighs 4.8 ounces. The Stay & Play collar is heavier at 10.2 ounces. You should consider your pet's size and strength when choosing. Heavier collars may be more durable but could be less comfortable for smaller animals.
Do these collars fit dogs over 5 pounds?
The Stay & Play collar is described as fitting pets over 5 pounds. The Stubborn Dog collar is targeted at dogs generally. You should verify the fit for your specific animal. Both collars are designed to be secure while allowing for natural movement.
What colors are available for these receiver collars?
The Stubborn Dog collar comes in red and black. The Stay & Play collar is listed in black. You can choose based on your preference or visibility needs. The color does not affect the technical performance or correction levels of the device.
Is a remote control included with these collars?
The provided data does not mention a remote control for these specific receiver collars. They are designed to work with the wireless fence transmitter. You should check your system manual for details on how the collar communicates with the boundary signal for containment.
